NAKBA anniversary: ambassadors in Hungary send a message to the Palestinian people – VIDEO

7 Comments

1. Except that Wikipedia has a bias against Israel. The Nakba was when the UN created the state of Israel and the Palestinians refused a state and together with other Arabs countries attacked Israel and lost the war. Also at this time over 800,000 Jews were ethnically cleansed from Arab countries and all of their possessions and property was stolen. They have been trying to twist history and eliminate Israel ever since then!

2. Maybe instead of ranting about the past and living in a fantasy world in which a country of ten million people somehow folds and disappears, these guys could do something constructive for a change.

   • Nice nonsense of you Michael at 6:23 in the morning. 😀

     Israel is often viewed as a foreign imposition in the Middle East, established after Jews faced persecution and massacres in Europe—primarily at the hands of Christians. Historically, Jewish communities found refuge in many Muslim-majority countries, where they lived alongside Arab and other populations for centuries. Notably, around 40 Muslim-majority nations refused to cooperate with the Nazis or deport Jews during the Holocaust, demonstrating a legacy of coexistence.

     However, the creation of Israel as a supremacist state for one group has led to injustice against Palestinians. The mass displacement and killings of Palestinians are unacceptable, and they must be allowed to return to their homes. Jews who migrated to Palestine from Europe, Russia, or elsewhere do not have greater rights to the land than its indigenous Palestinian inhabitants. A just solution must reject ethnic supremacy and uphold equality for all.

3. Radz-
   It’s clear you don’t have an understanding of the history of the Land

   1. Jews are indigenous to the Land of Israel. Proven extensively by historians, archaeologists, and even DNA.
   2. Jews are very happy to share the land with others. The partition plan and many other peace agreements were rejected by Arab leaders (see Bill Clintons comments on this)
   3. Jews were massacred by Muslims/Arabs well before the modern State of Israel. See Hebron Massacre or the Farhud for some 20th century examples.
   4. Palestinians are the only people in the world who 80+ years later are considered refugees. Even if someone has one great grandparent who left British Mandate Palestine in 1945 they are conferred refugee status. Bella Hadid is considered a refugee under your definition! No other people demand such a ridiculous “Right of Return” that would overwhelm the State of Israel and lead to another genocide of the Jewish people.

   • Trust me I know more than you do about the region. I am descended from there :D. I will try to answer your points as follows:

     1. Even though Israel’s archaeological efforts have revealed rich historical layers, no single discovery definitively “proves” exclusive belonging. The evidence underscores a mosaic of cultures—Canaanite, Egyptian, Nabatean, and others—complicating nationalist narratives. The debate remains entwined with modern politics, as seen in disputes over jurisdiction and heritage preservation.

     2. Dont speak about DNA test, while it is the only country on planet earth that it is prohibited to do it in is ISRAEL. 😀

     3. it’s hypocritical when on one hand Zionists use the UN GA partition plan as a pretext to legitimize Israel’s existence, while they’ve rejected almost every other UN resolution since Israel’s creation, chief among them UN GA resolution 194 that called for the immediate return to all Palestinian refugees to their homes in Israel.

     4. Jewish communities historically experienced greater tolerance under Muslim rule in places like Al-Andalus and the Ottoman Empire compared to Christian Europe. While isolated incidents of persecution occurred, they were not systematic or comparable to the widespread violence Jews faced in Christian lands.

     5. Finally, the right of return is very important to the indigenous people since it is their right, and shall not be barred by lapse of time. The Israeli project, even it give a safe heaven for Jews, but it killed and displaced many people from the region and they deserve justice.

     I highly recommend reading and following Máté Gábor since he is Hungarian and holocaust survivor. 😀

4. Radz-
   I appreciate your responses. But I don’t just descend from there, I lived in the region 10 years and did 2 degrees on the subject.

   Your answers have truth but you didn’t answer the core arguments

   1. DNA tests being allowed in Israel is irrelevant. There are enough studies showing European Jews are indigenous to Israel.

   2. Israels approach to the UN is again not the subject of discussion. Israel accepted the partition plan and a half dozen other peace proposals that would create a State for the Palestinians. None were accepted by the Palestinians. You can criticize Israels approach and even call them hypocrites in this regard but the fact remains- since 1948 Israel has not a Palestinian partner for peace (ironically, no one made the same demands of Jordan when they occupied the West Bank and Jerusalem from 1948-1967)

   3. Refugee status being conferred to future generations and even when people have taken citizenship and begun their lives in a new country is a fallacy and unique to the Palestinians. Anyone with any understanding knows that this is both not how refugees status works (share any other modern example) and in practice, grating a Right of Return to 5+ million Arab and Muslim descendants of people who lived in the area 80+ years ago would render Israel “Judenrein”

   • Hi Sam,
     Thanks for your reply. I lived there for more than 26 years as well before moving out.
     let me shortly answer your points:
     1. Studies shows that Palestinians have 80% DNA proofs that they are from he region as well. This still give them the right to be there as well as any other ethnicity or religion.
     Though, you didn’t answer me why DNA test is being prohibited? what about Jews from eastern EU who don’t not show proof of DNA? should they be exiled?
     The whole DNA things is nonsense in my opinion, since now Hungarians can have the right to go back to Mongolia and live their since their DNA show they descended from that region!

     2. Israel would never accept peace plan since the establishment of it was based on supremacy, continuous expansion and ethnic cleansing. And yet the IDF wear a map on their shoulder shows their expansion plans to Jordan, Egypt, Syrian, Lebanon and parts of Turkey and KSA.
     My point, is whatever we may call the state that may contain those people and religious, there should be not supremacy of anyone over anyone.

     3. The world represented by 50+ countries that time after the UK mandate does not have the right to establish a country where another people are already there including Jews!!!. The Palestinians should have the right of return since it is the only colony on planet earth where occupier could not kill all indigenous people as happened in the USA, Australia or New Zealand. Simply the Palestinians are not accepting to die as expected.

     😀 Finally, and again why not to have a country (whatever named) which hosts all those people together without supremacy? all have the same rights and duties? Why Palestinians have to hold responsible for the atrocities done to Jews in Europe and Russia by killing +6 m Jews?